- Erin Spineto

- 4 min read
It seems that lately, everyone has been on the 'I-Hate-Third-Act-Breakups' bandwagon. I’ve spent the last few months trying to figure out why. And what I realized is that there is no such thing as a third-act break-up.
At least not in traditional story theory.
Now, before you stop reading, thinking this is some academic diatribe about why current stories suck, let me say that the feeling of disappointment readers get when there is an unnecessary break-up between characters at that 75% mark is real. And it comes because it shouldn’t have been there in the first place.
You see, in traditional storytelling, there are certain things that humans like to see in order for a story to feel compelling and for the ending to feel satisfying. First, there is the Normal World, what life is like before your story really begins. And then there is the Call to Adventure, which the protagonist will at first deny, but eventually accepts at the 25% mark. Then they spend the second quarter of the story being confronted with this new world and, with it, the fact that they have believed a lie about themselves or the world that no longer works in this New Adventure World. At the halfway mark, they begin to try out this new truth and spend the third quarter seeing if it fits.
At the 75% mark, where the "Third Act Breakup” usually happens, is when they reject this new truth and try to go back to their old Normal World. They then realize that they can no longer go back to believing that old lie, now that they have been on their adventure. So, they grieve for that old world and then commit to the New Truth and seek to live in their New Normal World while living in alignment with their new truth.
In a romance, the desire to go back to their Old Normal World in full rejection of the New Truth often causes a break up of the couple. It became so common to see a couple break-up at this moment that storytellers began to conflate the break-up with what had to happen at the 75% mark, so they began to write a breakup there. They had to make it make sense, so they created some pretty convoluted reasons to make that happen. And readers could tell that it wasn’t satisfying. So, they began to hate the Third Act Breakup because it didn’t feel authentic. And that’s because it wasn’t authentic.
So many contemporary romances that I've read lately have forgotten that stories should be about characters going on a Hero’s Journey. That they are discovering things about themselves and the world around them, things they have mistakenly believed were true but actually hurt them to believe. And so these stories have just become about a Meet Cute, some RomCom hijinks, a big kiss, and then a breakup.
When a romance, or any story really, is about people learning and growing and discovering that lie that won’t work for them anymore, that breakup becomes real, driven by their fear of embracing a new truth. The Dark Night of the Soul that comes after the breakup isn’t just about losing a relationship, but the reckoning that comes with discovering that something you believed about yourself or the world isn’t true and never has been. And, even more than that, has been hurting you and those around you for as long as you can remember.
This realization then lends more power to the moment and makes the couple’s reconnection so much more valuable and life affirming. It becomes about a universal truth that we can walk away from the story and apply it to our own lives.
In all of my stories, I have a Third-Act Breakup, but each time, they are driven by both characters discovering the lie they each believed was just that, a lie and that they both embrace the new truth that their relationship has helped them discover. Because relationships, good relationships, are ones where each person challenges the other and causes them to grow–where one partner’s strengths and life experiences help the other’s weaknesses and blind spots. The best couples I know have beautifully complimentary strengths so that each grows as they are sharpened by their partner.
What's your favorite or most satisfying third-act breakup moment from a book or movie (the good ones that feel authentic, not contrived!). Let's build a list of the breakups that actually work.
P.S. Enjoyed today’s wave of words? The Salties Scoop brings even more: raw writing moments, secret playlists, laugh-out-loud stories, and those deep heart-tugs that make the Warrior Women world come alive—all landing gently in your inbox. 🌅💌
Hop on board (it’s my favorite place to hang out with readers like you): 👉 Sign up here:
No spam, just sunshine and stories. Excited to share the next one with you! 🏖️😍







